Layers of NYC #31: Now...and Then?

Today's Layer Trivia is from Doug Nervik, one of my favorite guides of the city: 

 

At the northwest corner of Second Avenue and 6th Street there is now a sign for Emigrant Savings bank. It's a typical 25 foot wide lot, but it used to be the entrance to a _________________?

Layers of NYC #30: Then...and Now?

William Kissam Vanderbilt and his wife, Alva, moved a few blocks south of the Marble Row into the first house equipped with electricity.  (Thomas ALVA Edison--bizarre coincidence--furnished the technology.) 

What Fifth Avenue store (that sells magic, thunder, and heat) now occupies the lot where that Vanderbilt mansion once glowed?

Layers of NYC #29: Then...and Now?

When Mary Mason Jones and her sister moved uptown and built Marble Row near Central Park, they were considered pioneers--the wealthy lived downtown near Washington Square and Gramercy Park.  The fringe of the park was considered the Wilderness.  It wasn't too long, however, before the wealthy followed the sisters uptown and this move, according to legend, is where we get the phrase "keeping up with the Joneses."

What store stands where the Marble Row once did?  (Hint:  to purchase something here is to keep up with the Joneses in the modern sense.)

Layers of NYC #28: Then...and Now? (And Actually Then)

This was New York's first grand auditorium.  Castle Garden was a massive opera house from 1840-1855 when the venue became America's first official immigration station.  From 1855-1890, the state and federal governments worked together to process the immigrants.  When the feds took over the job, New York State promptly evicted them.  (In 1892, Ellis Island opened.)  This building became the New York Aquarium until the 1940's.

What kind of edifice stands there now? 

(Hint:  it was also the original structure whose walls were part of the opera house, immigration station, and aquarium.)

Layers of NYC #27: Now...and Then?

Arguably, the ugliest of the four Madison Square Gardens, our present-day arena replaced what famous Beaux Arts structure? 

(Hint:  Its loss is one of the city's most infamous demolitions.)

Layers of NYC #26: Then...and Now?

The third Madison Square Garden (1925-1967), whose boxing ring was donated to the International Boxing Hall of Fame, was the MSG where Marilyn Monroe sang Happy Birthday to JFK.  This was also the arena whose construction crew included aspiring author, John Steinbeck. 

What building now stands where the third Madison Square Garden once did?

Layers of NYC #25: Now...and Then?

Cass Gilbert (architect of the Woolworth Building and the Custom House) built the beautiful headquarters for the New York Life Insurance Company from 1926-1928. 

 

But what famous structure had to be razed in order for the New York Life to rise?

Layers of NYC #24: Now...and Then?

On the site of Rockefeller Center was the site of America's first _________________?

Layers of NYC #23: Now...and Then?

Today, at the bottom of Broadway the Alexander Hamilton U.S. Custom House (home of a federal bankruptcy court and a museum dedicated to the Native American) stands in all its Beaux Arts splendor.  But what bulky building occupied this site from the 1620's until 1789 when it was finally demolished to clear the way for the new federal city?

Layers of NYC #22: Now...and Then?

Today, a fountain stands in the middle of Bowling Green, but what "first" was erected there in 1770 after the repeal of the Stamp Act?

(Hint:  The black iron fence surrounding the park was put up to protect this in 1771.)

Layers of NYC #21: Now...and Then?

What substance would the Dutch of the seventeenth century have found at the present-day intersections of Forty-Sixth and Twelfth Avenue, Wall and Front, and Washington and West Houston? 

(Hint:  This substance could also have been seen where the East Coast Memorial now stands in Battery Park and where the hospital buildings stand on Ellis Island.)

Layers of NYC #20: Then...and Now?

What abstract sculpture in Lower Manhattan stands on a corner where the first Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, John Jay, once lived?

Layers of NYC #19: Then...and Now?

There was a mansion in Lower Manhattan called Richmond Hill (demolished 1849) that served as the first Vice Presidential mansion for John Adams.  George Washington had used it as a headquarters in 1776 and Aaron Burr would later occupy it as a country home.

Today what off-Broadway house and what independent movie theater would you find closest to the site of that first Vice Presidential mansion?

Layers of NYC #18: Then...and Now?

What sort of structure now stands where Thomas Jefferson lived while Secretary of State (57 Maiden Lane)?

What structures now stand where George Washington lived while president (1 Cherry Street and 37 Broadway)?

Layers of NYC #17: Then...and Now?

According to popular legend, what restaurant operates in Aaron Burr's former carriage house?

Layers of NYC #16: Then...and Now?

This week's questions will focus on the days of New York as the nation's first capital.

The first question will be easy.  Name the intersection in Lower Manhattan where the first capital was located and where George Washington was inaugurated?  And what building now stands in its place?

Layers of NYC #15: Then...and Now?

This local island was known as Lesser Island (Minnissais) and Great Oyster Island.  It was named after Isaac Bedloe in 1667 and retained that name for 290 years.  It was the city's first quarantine station during a smallpox epidemic and was used as a refuge for Loyalists on the eve of the Revolution.  It also served as a recruitment camp and ordnance depot during the Civil War.

Name that island.

Answer after the jump.

Layers of NYC #14: Then...and Now

This local island was known as Hog Island and had farms as early as 1639.  The king of England granted it to John Manning in 1668.  In 1675, after John Manning surrendered Fort James, allowing the Dutch to briefly reclaim the city, the king of England exiled Manning to the island for cowardice and treason.  Manning's son-in-law, Robert Blackwell, inherited the island, and the Blackwells owned it until 1828.

The city purchased it and built a workhouse, an almshouse, a madhouse, and a penitentiary (which housed both Boss Tweed and Mae West).  In 1887, Nellie Bly famously went undercover to expose conditions at the island's lunatic asylum.  In 1921, it was renamed Welfare Island.  With its history, it was known as a "home for the unfortunate and suffering." 

Today?  Not so much.

Name that island. 

Answer after the jump.

Layers of NYC #13: Then...and Now?

This local island was known as Kioshk Island in 1600, Gull Island by 1630, Oyster or Little Oyster Island by 1680, Bucking Island by 1730, and Gibbet or Anderson Island (Anderson was a sailor hanged here from a gibbet) by 1765. 

What is the present name of this island?

Answer after the jump.

Layers of NYC #12: Then...and Now?

This local island was where the first eight European settlers lived in 1624 before following their dreams and moving to Manhattan the following year.  In the early 1700's the city used the island to quarantine thousands of German Protestants expelled by Louis XIV.  In 1755, during the French and Indian War, it served to quarter the 51st Regiment of the British Colonial Militia.  Until 1997, it was the oldest continually active military base in the United States.

Name that island.

Answer after the jump.

Layers of NYC #11: Then...and Now?

This local island was where the first eight European colonists set their cattle to pasture in 1624.  Known later as York Island, it was almost entirely deforested by the end of the American Revolution.  Name that island.

Answer after the jump.

Layers of NYC #10: Then...and Now?

In The Great Gatsby (1925), the Valley of Ashes between East Egg and the City serves as a metaphorical wasteland.  The ash heaps were not a literary invention.  They actually existed and were located in Queens.  Fitzgerald saw this part of town--a giant dump with piles of ash reaching up to ninety feet--as the antithesis of "the fresh, green breast of the new world."  Within fourteen years, however, this part of the city would be completely cleaned up in order to showcase a bright, new vision of the future.

What precipitated the transformation and what stands there now?

Answers after the jump.

Layers of NYC #9: Then...and Now?

A body of water, formerly known as the "Fresh Water Pond" and then "the Collect," became a polluted swamp that required drainage via a canal in the early 1800's.  A neighborhood rose from the mud to become a slum known as "the Five Points," so infamous that the streets themsleves were renamed or removed entirely.  To pinpoint exactly where the original streets intersected, you'll need maps, but ROUGHLY:  what district now stands where the Five Points once did?

Layers of NYC #8: Then...and Now?

Following up on yesterday's question, what famous Broadway theater (opened 1911) sits at the top of what was the Long Acre Farm on the site of W.K. Vanderbilt's American Horse Exchange (1896)?

(Hint:  Its longest running show turned the block from equine to feline.)

Layers of NYC #7: Then...and Now?

Prior to 1904, Longacre Square was filled with horse exchanges, carriage factories, stables, and blacksmith shops.  What is the name of this area today?

Answer after the jump.